Disney Planes. A Movie Review by Owen Zupp.

Owen Zupp - Friday, August 16, 2013


A Movie Review.

Famous movie franchises can be like famous families. They can benefit from association, but they can also suffer at the hands of unending comparisons. And this may well be the case for 'Planes'.

In terms of a movie, 'Cars' was a massive success and taking this tale to the next level was undoubtedly the goal for Disney. In terms of media, marketing and merchandising, transforming 'Cars' into 'Planes' was a relatively straightforward exercise, however, it was a greater leap of faith to transform the movie.

Without being a spoiler, the 'Cars' template was overlaid on the 'Planes' concept and then tweaked here and there. The backdrop is once again a race circuit, albeit around the world, and the shifting fortunes play out on a leader board. The central character is not a shiny 'Lightning McQueen', but the little plane that could. Once again, a wise old character tempers the star's impetuosity and there is even a love interest, although it has shifted to a pair of co-stars.

There is no escaping the quality of the film's production. The animation, 'camera' angles, settings and colour are all first class. The audience even captures a sense of flight as the aircraft pitch and roll about the big screen. Visually, 'Planes' is captivating.

What is missing to some degree is the humour stemming from spontaneity that 'Cars' brought to the table. Achieving this was always going to prove a difficult task given that the first franchise had set a benchmark of great expectations and conjured preconceptions in the minds of the audience. Funnily enough, if a template was being applied, this film may have benefited from employing another 'Mater'. A goofy side-kick providing comic relief right on cue.

Personally, I enjoyed 'Planes', but then again, I couldn't sit more in the centre of Disney's target demographic profile if I tried. I am an aviation enthusiast with a young family. I was always probably going to give this film '5 Stars' as it offers another opportunity to share cherished laughter and common ground with my children. However, the real test for 'Planes' will come from those not so centrally located in Disney's cross-hairs. Can it possibly have the far-reaching impact of the highly successful 'Cars' films? It is a very, very tough act to follow. In the future, 'Planes 2' could actually benefit from being one step removed from the other franchise and build upon its own identity.

For me, there is one final acid test for the film. I was lucky enough to see the movie on its opening day in the United States, but I am now keen to see the looks on my own kids' faces when 'Planes' lands here in Australia. Only then will I be able to truly rate the success of 'Planes'. I'll get back to you then...

Andy Hawkins commented on 16-Aug-2013 08:35 PM
I'm seeing 'Planes' tomorrow with my daughter and her friend (4 and 5 years old). Hope they enjoy it!

Andy Hawkins commented on 19-Aug-2013 08:11 PM
Not great news I'm afraid. I have to say I thought it was 'Ok', but my daughter (who has been to see plenty of films at the cinema) announced it was 'too long' about an hour or so in. I can only assume she was getting a bit bored of it perhaps.

She did sit through the whole thing with a bit of persuasion, and seems to have enjoyed it, but it was far from Pixar's finest (yes, I know it wasn't a true Pixar film, but John Lasseter was credited as providing the story...

Not a *bad* film by any stretch, but could easily have been so much better I fear.


Post a Comment

Captcha Image

Trackback Link
Post has no trackbacks.

Recent Posts


Kenneth McGlashan WW1 bombing of Darwin Boeing 737 Ferry Flight Kimpo wings night war Kingsford Smith Airport US Airways Flight 1549 Shuttleworth Collection learn to fly Pitts air australia Bombardier rescue airliner missing top tips Nancy Bird ambulance Glenn McGrath Temora Aviation Museum 747-8F 50 tales of fllight Malaysia Airlines DH Mosquito Australian Aviation magazine cricket Korean War Paramedic STOL maiden flight bachelor of aviation Facebook aviation speaker EFIS ditching an airplae ANZAC Day planes pilot academy Steve Visscher Nancy Bird-Bird Walton FA-18 Hornet flying Airbus A330 737-400 deHavilland Mosquito army cost of flying Boeing 777 1940 VH-OQA safer flying T-6 Pearl Harbor Grant McHerron Area 51 Titanic sinking landing an arplane popular aviation blog aviation jobs sailor Planes Premiere pilot training iTunes Q400 RNP caribou QANTAS Boeing 747-400 EADI Winglets Matt Hall 787 airbus aviation book cirrus crash pilot suicide aerodynamic stall Vietnam War WW2 Ricky Ponting how to land an aeroplane One Six Right ATFV Spitfire Boeing 747-400 hars HGS airman sport solo flight. australia 723 squadron future open day Kenneth McGlashan: Hawker Hurricane flight training Yak Formation aircraft accident avspecs The Battle of Britain GFC Commercial pilot licence Australian Army flight ditching Yak 18T Gloster Meteor airline collapse flying instructor solo around australia Boeing 747-8F how to land an airplane J170 arospace tailwheel Steve Waugh Foundation there and back simpler time learning to fly raked wing-tip Ansett Australia warbirds aviation story Flying Wing McGrath Foundation firts solo Brumby Evolution aviation writer Aviation Photography Chris Sperou solo flight australia Bf109 pilot jobs Solo Flight Australia. Boeing 767 Honolulu coosing a flight school Lord of the Rings cumulonimbus US Navy aviation image aviation photography MH370 open cockpit flight ebook commercial pilot license storm cells landing an aeroplane Queenstown Supermarine Spitfire most popular aviation blog amazon aircraft Boeing 747-8i Steve Cooke Sydney Australia Rolls Royce Merlin QANTAS most poular aviation blog land an aeroplane Milford Sound Boeing 737NG flying school MH370 found metal detectors biofuel spitfire 944 Jetstar keynote speaker the Fatal Stall poppies Duxford aeroplane memorial 77 Squadron Bell 429 Beechcraft Glass revolution Boeing Airbus A380 buying an aeroplane QANTAS engineers Air France 447 ditching an aeroplane Scouts P-40 Kittyhawk The Hobbit A350 XWB Brumby coastal flying Dash 8 terrorism Mystery Aircraft Texas ZA003 aviaton author student pilot Bundaberg plane crash how to land anthony jackson airliners.net aviation blog flying schoold CAC Wirraway aerospace Tiger Moth ICAO airlines solar Fleet Air Arm warbird owen zupp author USS Arizona Ayers Rock R-DX EFATO Uluru Garmin G1000 QANTAS Boeing 737 principles of flight Bell 429 helicopter pilot blog QANTAS Boeing 737-800 9/11 50 tales of flight QANTAS A380 smashwords disney planes Battle of Britain Dunkirk Boeing 787 Dreamliner DX-R CO2 emissions Boeing 737-800 aerobatics Blue Angels careers in aviation Seattle HUD Nancy Bird Walton administration Bush Pilot 1942 blog Cessna beyond blue A350 flying ebook USS Missouri fatal stall landing a jet Cessna Caravan forced landing flying blog QANTAS pilots 38 Squadron RAAF Around Australia flight amazon best seller K.I.A ballooning Brumby 610 formation flying green technology Plane Crazy Down Under missing airliner QANTAS Airbus A380 p Owen Zupp jabiru masters of aviation management Piper 400 memory Garmin Costa Concordia glass cockpit boeing 737 P-51 Mustang best aviation blog Australian War Memorial CAC Boomerang airplane New Zealand: QANTAS Bert Hinkler kitplanes G-force Red Baron stick and rudder 16R aeroplane blog SCAT airshow Super Hornet QF94 Yak 52 tom wolfe addresses Gen-X engines DC-3 Victorian Air Ambulance RFC Pacific Warbirds Queenstown New Zealand Day of Infamy airline 5 flying tips buying an airplane Special Casualty Access Team Lockheed Hudson Avalon Air Show MXS baggy green flying kangaroo Avalon 2013 mosquito a aviation J230D Owen Zupp, fly at Ansett coaxial QANTAS Formula One Grand Prix life saving aviation aero club September 11 Sir Donald Bradman deCrespigny the sky is not the limit aviation consultant bowral RMS Titanic airliner A320 Flight 6231 aeromedical Kenneth Butterworth McGlashan Blackhawk aviation degree RAF Ernest Gann Red Bull 737NG the right stuff aviation consulatant low pass Jabiru Aircraft the bombing of Darwin Down to Earth writing ANZAC CRT 737 soldier flying career Cathay Pacific manuscript tail rotor fling aviator Bradman ghost NTSB Diamond DA40 Korean Air War Ponting Foundation NSW Ambulance Service Strategic Airlines SNJ Japanese Zero RAAF Beech King Air D-Day choosing a flying school Edwards Air Base Steve Waugh UAV engine failure www.owenzupp.com Se5a Hawker Hurricane QANTAS announcement Jatstar Airbus dogfight airport security solo flight flying training Scimitar CA18 Mustang san francisco Defence Force Recruiting Flying Podcast Pearl Harbour flight school aviation journalist QF32 Super King Air QANTAS half yearly report de Crespigny buting an aeroplane aviation eBook Asiana skipper Kitplane flight blog Chuck Yeager Highlander airplane Northwest Orient canyoner Mick Wilson National Press Club Dreamliner FA-18 contrail wings hustling hinkler Bulldog Pitts Singapore September 11th Sullenberger Mittagong Airfield low flying pilot careers North American Harvard landing an airplane coaxe Impossible Airport biplae NASA Puffin Bradman Foundation 0/11 Cb dusty Air Ambulance armore airpot flight deck PCDU Cathay Pacific Cargo G-ROBT Wallaby Airlines solo flight. asutralia speaking 737 classic Royal Australian Navy 2012 Flying Fortress speaker QANTAS QF32 George Hale B777 plane crash Caboolture fly at International Cricket Hall of Fame pilot contra-rotating propeller New Zealand disney pixar B-17 first flight Flight for Control Canberra Brumby High Wing building your own aeroplane Boeing 787 Brumby Aircraft Terwilliger Productions BAE Hawk RAA aviation author P2902 C-47 Honolulu Airport owen zupp Hong Kong Trader Boeing 747 Australia aviation careers short field Ice Pilots Pump Up the Angels Sydney Airport Douglas DC-3 bell X-1 737-300 hijack GenX Airbus A320 australian aviation


© Owen Zupp. All rights Reserved.                                             Admin . Privacy . Disclaimer                                            Website by Shot to Pieces . Powered by Blackroom